Search

Resources

Asante’s Layoff Warnings Highlight the Need for Financial Transparency

Layoffs Demand More Than Broad Explanations

Asante Health System is the dominant hospital provider in southern Oregon, serving Grants Pass, Ashland, and Medford. Oregonians living here do not have any other alternatives for hospital-level care. Recent news reports about Asante’s warning that hundreds of layoffs may be necessary has sparked criticism from the community and concern from many nurses about access to care. When business decisions affect patient care and access to services, communities deserve a clear understanding of the financial realities driving those choices.

The debate should not be limited to one press release or one quarter of financial results. Decisions that impact caregivers, patients, and regional health care access should be viewed in the context of a health system’s long-term financial performance.

That is the purpose of FamilyCare Health’s Hospital Transparency Report. Using publicly available financial information, including IRS Form 990 filings, audited financial statements, and Oregon Health Authority disclosures, the report provides a statewide view of hospital profitability and financial strength. The goal is not to judge individual decisions, but to give policymakers, community leaders, and the public the information needed to better understand them.

Understanding Asante’s Financial Context

According to FamilyCare’s analysis, Asante generated approximately $644 million in cumulative net income from 2013 through 2023. During that period, it reported an average net margin of 7%, the highest among Oregon health systems included in the report. Its net assets grew from approximately $578 million to $1.17 billion, an increase of more than 100%.

That does not mean Asante has been immune to financial challenges. Like many hospitals, it experienced a difficult year in 2022, reporting a significant loss. But the broader picture also shows a return to profitability in 2023 and further margin improvement in 2024.

Both realities can be true: short-term financial pressures and long-term financial strength.

Questions Communities Deserve Answered

When layoffs are proposed, communities deserve answers to several basic questions:

  • How much financial capacity has been built over time?
  • How have those resources been used to support patient care and workforce stability?
  • What alternatives were considered before reducing staff?
  • How will layoffs affect patients and access to care?
  • What tradeoffs are being made, and why?

These are not criticisms. These are the questions that hospital executives should be prepared to answer when communities hold them accountable.

Nonprofit hospitals occupy a unique position in their communities. They benefit from dominant market positions, public trust, tax advantages, charitable support, and substantial public reimbursement. In return, it is reasonable for communities to expect transparency when major decisions could affect access to care.

Transparency Builds Trust

Asante’s financial performance does not immediately answer the question of whether layoffs are justified. But it does suggest that the conversation should extend beyond broad references to financial pressure alone.

Health systems face difficult decisions, particularly in today’s challenging health care environment. Yet when those decisions involve hundreds of caregivers, the public deserves a complete picture of the financial tradeoffs involved.

Transparency is not about assigning blame. It is about building trust, informing public discussion, and ensuring that communities have the information necessary to understand decisions that affect their health care system.

When the health of our community is at stake, clarity and accountability are critical.

FamilyCare Health

Determinants of Health: Access to Healthcare, Public Health, Hospitals

Related Resources

We learned valuable lessons running FamilyCare Health Plans for more than 30 years. Our proven track record shows that addressing the social, economic, and behavioral drivers of health improves outcomes while reducing costs. Now, as an independent non-profit, we're committed to sharing these insights and helping transform the healthcare system.